A Student-Focused NCAA Needs an Athletics Majors

A Student-Focused NCAA Needs Athletics Majors

Image from Studentscholarships.org

As part of a larger series on reinventing college, Brad Wolverton of the Chronicle of Higher Education wrote a piece about creating a student-focused NCAA. As arguments for NCAA reform go, it is decidedly on the side of turning athletics back to the core mission of the university rather than embracing the business side. The piece is for Chronicle subscribers only, and the devil is in the details, but here are the five changes Wolverton suggests.

Wolverton’s Five Proposed Changes

  1. Make coaches faculty members who also teach.
  2. Reduce athletic commitments so athletes have more opportunities in college.
  3. Give players a greater voice (or voting) in NCAA governance.
  4. Beef up due process and privacy protections for student-athletes.
  5. Help student-athletes with job placement following college.

All are great suggestions, although the crowd on the other side of the aisle will likely cringe at some of them. Compared to some of the other changes suggested, like no grades and starting primary education at age three, Wolverton’s ideas seem trivial in the grand scheme of higher education.

All of these proposals are repairs or changes to a system that increasingly looks unworkable. Each suggestion seeks to strike a better balance between athletics and education, between protections for students and the quest for revenue. None of these change the relationship between athletics and academics to the point where managing balance is no longer needed because balance is inherent.

The NCAA has tried quite a few things. The most highly touted has been the Academic Progress Rate, which gives coaches and administrators an incentive to graduate student-athletes. But the incentives are targeted at eligibility, retention, and graduation, rather than capturing the more fluid concept of education. For all the good it has done, the APR has lead to things like increased clustering, the growth of academic support departments, and the potential for increased academic fraud.

The constant push has been to hold down athletics as an extracurricular activity, and increase the role of academics. But to change the game, we need to go in the other direction and meld athletics with academics by establishing majors in athletics for student-athletes.

The Arguments For Athletics Majors Have Been Made Many Times Before, But Here is a Quick Summary:

  • Athletics has few or no significant differences from other artistic or entertainment pursuits.
  • We see value in the study of artistic pursuits despite the long odds of making a living purely on talent in those fields.
  • Increases in injuries, especially concussions, make the study of athletes more important than ever.
  • Elite athletes need education in personal finance, agent and advisor selection, marketing, and interacting with the media.
  • Youth sports need more professionally trained coaches who know both best practices in teaching a sport as well as first aid, CPR, and injury management training.

But athletics majors also address many of the problems identified in Wolverton’s article and make all of his suggestions significantly easier.

If coaches are professors for their athletes, they are integrated into the faculty without needing to find them something to teach. If the bulk of a coach’s teaching responsibilities involve coaching the varsity team, the coaching profession will likely be less resistant to the change. Hopefully as athletically-related majors grow, coaches end up teaching a greater and greater percentage of non-athletes.

A student-athlete’s total time commitment will be reduced, by creating a greater overlap of academic and athletic activities. All academic commitments will not disappear, since there will still be general education requirements as well as increased academic focus and study on a student-athlete’s athletic activities. But there will almost certainly be a reduction of total required activities, including those that are nominally voluntary.

Majors in athletics have a more indirect effect on student-athlete involvement in NCAA governance. That will require governance changes from the adults in charge of the NCAA or forced from the outside. But what it will do is make the experience of athletes more uniform, which means less chance that the athletes involved in NCAA governance have a different experience than other athletes, particularly those in revenue sports.

By making athletics an academic pursuit rather than an extra- or co-curricular activity, the case for stronger due process protections becomes almost impossible to oppose. It gets much harder to defend coaches being allowed to kick athletes off a team, much less take away their scholarships, without oversight because it would mean kicking students out of their major. Same for athletes who wish to transfer, since every transfer would be an academic transfer.

Finally, an athletics major brings with it a built-in job placement program by preparing athletes for jobs that coaches are familiar with. Coaches have the networks already, which they needed to build in order to get to the college level. Plus if the team is also part of the major, job placement becomes a part of the recruiting process like placing players in professional leagues is now.

The idea that college athletics is trying to strike an impossible balance is becoming a popular one, and numerous potential conflicts have been identified. The one noticed by Brad Wolverton is of athletics as an extracurricular activity which also generates significant revenue. The solution is to abandon the idea that varsity athletics is an extra curricular activity and turn it into the curriculum itself.

Do you think colleges should add an athletics major for athletes to their curriculum? Let us know in the comments section below, or connect with us on Facebook, Twitter, or Google+!

Is my high school coach going to get me recruited? Can I rely on the coach or do I need to get out there and do it myself?

What are the questions I need to prepare when contacting the college coach for the first time?

Is there a college recruiting timeline I need to know about? How long does it take?

You need to do your research if you want to  get recruited and earn a sports scholarship.

what are the NCAA rules about a scholarship athlete transferring?

 

Posted on by John Infante
This entry was posted in Bylaw Blog, Bylaws. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to A Student-Focused NCAA Needs an Athletics Majors

  1. B. David Ridpath says:

    A couple things are critical here–there are already sports and coaching focused majors in many colleges and universities today. When I discuss this topic–which is very valid-many (not all) think that an “athletic major” will be just going to practice and playing i.e. majoring in their sport. If this happens, understand that there will still be reading, writing, and arithmetic via general education requirements and classes that focus on athletics and sports. This gets lost in the translation many times. It is not and will not be an end around academics nor should academic standards be relaxed. At Mississippi State I was literally threatened by a former AD to not raise our coaching curriculum GPA standards for admission to a 2.5–a 2.5 for gods sake.

    Here at Ohio University we have Sports Administration on campus and online for grad students who want to pursue administration at the professional and collegiate sports levels, an athletic administration masters degree for those who want to pursue High School athletic administration, also a masters coaching curriculum, and numerous undergraduate options. I do agree that there can be more focus on some of the specifics mentioned above and even a new degree program, but something very close to this already exists in many forms and are available to athletes. Many do not take advantage of it because of academic requirements or cajoling from coaches to take an easier major (read–forced). Any redevelopment of these degree programs still have to have the academic rigor of a college degree and not just be practice and competing as a way to soften academics even more. Coaches teaching is not a bad idea and has been done successfully before, but there has to be checks against the Jim Harrick Jrs of the world who might have competitive eligibility in mind more than a real education.

    This sounds good in practice and briefs well but there is much more to consider.

    • John Infante says:

      Crafting an athletics major is a book-length topic, but a couple of thoughts.

      1. You will still have general education requirements. One benefit though to an athletics major is that you can front load some athletics courses, reduce academic load, and still do remediation, i.e. teaching underprepared students basic skills. And you can do that without changing eligibility rules.

      2. I don’t think you can grade courses in these majors. Grading courses either involves assuming coaches will do the right thing and rigorously grade their courses or building a big expensive infrastructure to provide checks and balances. There are numerous other ways to do evaluation in these courses (although you still need some checks).

      3. If there is something the NCAA has established a bit of expertise in, it is in certifying courses and curriculums and investigating whether they are academically sound. I think what the NCAA needs to do in order to enable this is less about allowing it and more about helping it by acting as more or less the accrediting agency. That means rules like only allowing schools to provide these majors to athletes if the program is approved by the NCAA.

  2. David Frank says:

    I worry that majoring in sports would cause athletes to not fully appreciate the academic components associated with “working in sports”. There is a big jump from playing a sport to coaching or working within the organization.

    The fundamental problem is that athletes don’t accept the currency of getting a free education as what they should be paid as college athlete. I don’t think printing a new denomination of currency is going to change that.

  3. The Bearded Blog says:

    I support a reform in the academic/athletic model. I like to write about it. It makes it a lot easier to just link to my blog.

    Things need to change.

Leave a Comment